Skip to content

ASG vs Umarex: airsoft replicas compared

ASG has 171 replicas in the database, Umarex has 138. Here is how they compare by category, power, weight and Italy's 1 joule limit.

	ASG	Umarex
Replicas in database	171	138
From official source	93%	4%
Within 1 J	50%	37%
Median FPS	344	345
Median rifle weight	2,445 g	3,070 g
Median pistol weight	820 g	740 g
Main types	AEG (electric) 76, CO2 52, Spring 17	GBB (gas blowback) 82, CO2 25, AEG (electric) 20

Comparison of database figures, not a quality verdict. Percentages for the 1 J limit count only replicas with an energy value.

Assault rifles & carbines

ASG (8)

CZ Scorpion EVO 3 A1 Carbine 1.85 J
Accuracy International MK13 Compact Spring Black 1.80 J
Hybrid Series H-15 B.E.T Semi AEG 1.69 J
Hybrid Series H-15 Carbine semi AEG 1.69 J
Special Teams Carbine Gas 1.69 J
Steyr AUG A1 AEG Semi 1.59 J
Steyr AUG A3 AEG Semi 1.59 J
Arsenal AR-M7T AEG Semi Value Pack 1.56 J

Umarex (8)

G28 GBB DX - Tan (by VFC) 1.80 J
IWI Tavor SAR GBBR (by KWA) 1.80 J
G28 AEG DX - Black (by VFC) 1.72 J
G28 AEG DX - Tan (by VFC) 1.72 J
G28 DMR GBB - Tan (by VFC) 1.68 J
HK416D GBB Gen 3 Rifle (by VFC) 1.64 J
G3A3 GBB (by VFC) 1.49 J
GRS Custom HK417 Limited Benghazi Edition GBBR V2 (by VFC) 1.49 J

SMGs

ASG (8)

CZ Scorpion EVO 3 A1 B.E.T. Carbine AEG 1.85 J
CZ Scorpion EVO 3 A1 B.E.T. Carbine AEG Semi 1.85 J
CZ Scorpion EVO 3 A1 Carbine AEG Semi 1.85 J
CZ Scorpion EVO 3 Carbine AEG 1.85 J
CZ Scorpion EVO3A1 B.E.T. Carbine 1.49 J
CZ Scorpion EVO3A1 Carbine 1.49 J
CZ Scorpion EVO 3 A1 AEG 1.44 J
CZ Scorpion EVO 3 A1 AEG Flat Dark Earth 1.44 J

Umarex (8)

MP5A5 AEG - Zinc DieCasting Version (by VFC) 1.49 J
MP5SD3 Early Type SMG GBB V2 (by VFC) 1.49 J
MP40 Legends CO2 Version (by WinGun) 1.34 J
MP5A4 AEG (by VFC) 1.34 J
MP5A5 AEG (by VFC) 1.34 J
MP5A5 Gen 2 GBBR (by VFC) 1.34 J
MP7 AEG SMG Gen 2 (by VFC) 1.34 J
VFC MP7A1 AEG SMG (Lite Version) 1.34 J

DMR & sniper rifles

ASG (8)

Accuracy International AW .308 Spring Black 1.88 J
McMillan M40A3 sniper rifle spring black 1.88 J
Tactical sniper rifle gas black 1.88 J
Steyr Scout Sniper rifle Spring Black 1.82 J
TAC 6 CO2 Black 1.82 J
Urban sniper rifle spring black 1.82 J
Action Army T11 Pro spring 1.72 J
Action Army C1 Pro Gas/CO2 Black 1.69 J

Umarex (1)

VFC PSG-1 GBBR (Umarex) 1.49 J

Light machine guns

ASG (0)

–

Umarex (1)

VFC MG4 LMG AEG 1.01 J

Pistols

ASG (8)

Dan Wesson CO2 urban grey 8" 2.72 J
JUSTICE CO2 non-blowback black 1.96 J
Schofield CO2 Silver 6" 1.96 J
Steyr M9-A1 CO2 Non Blow Back 1.96 J
Dan Wesson 715 CO2 Steel Grey 6" 1.90 J
Dan Wesson CO2 Silver 6" 1.90 J
ISSC M22 CO2 CNB 1.90 J
BERSA THUNDER 9 PRO CO2 Non Blow Back 1.82 J

Umarex (8)

Full comparison →

More comparisons

Tokyo Marui vs ASG Tokyo Marui vs Umarex ARES vs ASG ARES vs Umarex VFC vs ASG VFC vs Umarex ASG vs EMG ASG vs G&G ASG vs Tanaka Works EMG vs Umarex G&G vs Umarex Umarex vs Tanaka Works